Customer Reviews

I Declare...

It is without an ounce of hyperbole that I declare these to be the best cookies I have ever tasted.

Jesse Kaufman


This place is absolutely amazingggggg! I have to confess… I’m an absolute cookie addict which makes it rare for me to say a cookie is 5 stars but WOW

Rachael Reynolds

Want something sweet?

Yum! Really delicious cookies in this new, local cookie shop. It is great to have a bakery open in the evenings after dinner when you want something sweet.

Kim Cullen

Perfectly Chocolatey

Stopped by yesterday to try the cookies for the first time. Didn't expect much. Boy was I wrong! The owner was behind the counter, just super sweet. And the cookies were so delicious. Perfectly chocolatey and moist inside. Made with real butter,real vanilla that you can actually taste. Highly recommend everyone go here!

Korinn Radcliffe

Delicious Cookies

Amazing, incredible, delicious cookies!!
I’m from NYC, stopped into Clarabell after exploring Gulf Gate in Sarasota, and WOW! I was taken back by how good these cookies taste, literally the best cookies I’ve ever had (and I’m comparing Clarabell to other NYC brands). Overall, delicious cookies, great great service, I can’t wait to comeback.

Mauricio Duran

Perfect Balance of Flavors

When you walk in to Clarabell’s the unmistakeable smell of quality butter, chocolate and sugar is a delectable warmup to what you’re about to taste. Welcoming environment, clean and well cared for. I tried 3 cookies all heavenly. Great taste appearance and size. Cookies were a perfect balance of flavors!

Melissa Albrecht
hand holding a stack of cookies